Canadian and American economics compared

Canada is under constant pressure to remain competitive with the United States. If it does not then forces such as the brain drain will occur, where the top Canadians emigrate to the U.S. If Canada falls behind corporations will also leave for the United States. The U.S. has far less to fear as any losses to Canada can be easily managed.

Despite the contrasts listed below Canada and the United States are extremely similar economically. They are both developed countries and are thus vastly closer to each other than to the majority of the world's countries. Canada also is by almost all economic indices closer to the United States than it is to Europe.

Boom and bust cycles in Canada and the United States are closely linked as are many indicies such as inflation and interest rates. Demographic patterns are also similar, with a slightly higher birth rate in the U.S. and a higher immigration rate in Canada.

Geography

In its quest to remain competitive Canada starts at an immediate disadvantage. Canada's harsh climate leads immediately to high costs for such things as heating. Workers are less likely to immigrate to Canada and the wealthy are more likely to leave for tropical climes.

The climate and Canada also contributes to higher transportation costs as planes, trains, and automobiles are all more expensive to operate than in much of the United States. Canada's low population density also makes transportation costs higher. More of a historical concern was that much of the country lacks natural river systems that could be easily used for transportation. Canada's terrain is also somewhat more rugged than the United States. The Rocky Mountains are more of an obstacle, and the mass of the Canadian Shield provides a formidable barrier to any links between Ontario and Manitoba.

Canada does have some distinct geographic advantages. The most important of these are its natural resources. Canada has vast supplies of timber, metals, and oil. Canada's terrain, despite the short growing season, is also very suitable for agriculture, especially on the prairies. The large river systems in the north are sources of cheap hydro-electric power. While the United States has large supplies of natural resources, these are not enough to meet domestic demands and they are forced to important many raw materials, a great deal of which come from Canada.

Government

Differences between government intervention in the economies of the two countries is most closely examined in Canada, because many feel that policies that more closely emulate the U.S. are preferable, while others disagree.

Taxation

The average tax rate in Canada is higher than in the United States. In Canada total tax revenue for every level of government equals about 36.8% of GDP, in the U.S. this is closer to 30%. There is some regional variation, however. A resident of oil rich Alberta pays less in taxes than a resident of high tax Massachusetts.

The taxes are applied differently as well. Canada's tax system is more heavily biased against the highest income earners, thus while Canada's tax rate is higher on average, the bottom fifty percent of the population is more lightly taxed than in the United States.

Canada also has a national sales tax of 7% on all purchases, while the U.S. federal government relies almost entirely on income taxes.

Canada has no inheritance tax while the United States still does, but the U.S. tax is currently scheduled to be abolished.

Social Programs

For their higher taxes Canada has a more complete system of social programs than the United States. These differences include only having public universities, having a national broadcaster in the CBC and, most notably, having a fully socialized health care system. The United States, however, spends far more on the military than Canada. The United States also spends far more of their per capita GDP on health care than does Canada while Canadians receive comparable, if not superior, care. The Canadian health care system is also very attractive to employers, as in Canada health care is mostly paid through income taxes, while in the United States most companies extend health benefits to full-time employees, something they do have to do in Canada.

Anti-trust

The United States has since the Sherman Anti-Trust Act been strongly opposed to monopolies. In Canada this has been far less of an issue and Canada has never had rigorously enforced rules against monopolization.

Fiscal Policy

Canada is generally forced to follow American fiscal policy quite closely, any large difference in interest rates could quickly lead to large problems for the Canadian economy. The U.S. Federal Reserve and the Bank of Canada both staunchly believe in fighting inflation while neither aggressively pursue policies of full employment. One difference that has emerged recently is that while Canada is still hewing closely to the balanced budgets policies of the 1990s the United States has moved into a heavy deficit, a policy both countries followed in the 1970s and 1980s.

Political Turbulence

Over the last few decades the Canadian economy may have been hurt by the threat of Quebec separatism, and Quebec's economy was almost certainly damaged. Events in the United States have also sometimes benefited Canadians. Draft dodgerss during the Vietnam War created a reverse brain drain that lasted for many years.

Market Size

One of the most important differences historically between Canada and the United States was the size of the two markets. When both nations had high tariffs the two countries did not have a unified market. Canada's smaller market led to higher prices and greater inefficiency.

A good example of this is the automobile industry. This can be clearly demarcated into two periods: before and after the free trade creating Auto Pact of 1969. Before Canada had its own production lines creating each of the models that would be sold in Canada. These factories would only make small production runs of each vehicle, requiring frequent, and expensive retoolings. The factories would also generally be smaller. Fewer varieties were also available to Canadian consumers. However, these cars were almost all still made by American companies. After the Auto Pact, the industry was transformed as a unified North American market was created. The Canadian factories were rebuilt to be much larger, but to make only one model that would be sold in both countries creating large economies of scale.

After the Second World War tariffs between the two countries gradually fell, with full free trade being established by the 1988 Canada-United States Free Trade Agreement. Some industries are still protected, however. These are mostly sensitive areas such cultural industries including publishing, television, and newspapers, which all of have stringent foreign ownership rules. Other areas such as the transport industry are also protected with Canadian control of the airlines and trains being viewed as in the national interest.

This tends to create far more monopolies in Canada. For instance that air travel industry in Canada is dominated by a single airline, Air Canada. Canada has long had to make a trade-off between monopolization and efficiency which the Untied States has not. The United States can support a number of airlines that are big enough to operate efficiently, and still have a competitive market. Canadians are forced to choose between small inefficient airlines that would be competitive, or one monopolistic airline that will generate its own inefficiency.

Another example of this trade off is the book industry which has recently switched models. Until the 1990s Canada had many small and fairly inefficient book stores. Then Chapters entered the market and quickly created a monopoly, eliminating the inefficiencies of smaller stores but potentially leading to a monopolisticly set price of books.

The larger market of the United States also contributes to the brain drain. Top Canadians will often find greater opportunities in the United States. An example of this is the entertainment industry. If Jim Carrey had remained in the Canada entertainment industry, he would have made far less money and would not be world famous. The Canadian film industry will never be able to match the American one because Canada’s thirty million people cannot buy enough tickets to allow hundred million dollar budgets and stars that earn 20 million.

Banking

Canada and the United States have long had very different banking systems. The United States' was copied from England while Canada's was taken from Scotland. The United States traditionally has had a plethora of banks, all with very few branches. This has lead to a competitive but unstable system, with many thousands of banks having collapsed during the United States' history. Canada has always had far fewer banks per capita, but the banks have been larger and quickly became nationwide. Canadian banks have many branches and distributed assets and Canada has only had one major bank, the Homestead Bank, collapse in its history. This dispersement has continued to this day. In 1995 in Canada the five largest banks, the Big Five, controlled 58.1 percent of Canadian domestic assets, while the five largest U.S. banks controlled only 9.7 percent of their domestic assets.)

Canada's banks have traditionally been much fiercer competitors internationally. Much of the banking system in the West Indies is controlled by the Canadian banks. Canadian banks also have far more of a presence in the United States than American firms do in Canada. In part this is because American firms cannot buy Canadian banks, but Canadian banks have, at times, been able to buy American ones. Since the large Canadian banks already operate nationwide chains of a thousand or more branches, they find it relatively easy to integrate smaller chains of American banks into their systems.

Despite these foreign ownership rules, Canadian banks have been far less strictly regulated than their American counterparts. Canadian banks are far freer to participate in the financial planning and insurance industries than their American counterparts. Canadian banks have not faced laws against usury, or interest guarantees on deposits. Profits for Canadian banks are generally higher.

However, service charges are also lower in Canada, and Canada's banking system also provides better service by most measures. Canada has more branches and more ATMs per capita than the United States. Checks take less time to clear, as to most other transactions. Canadian banks have been far more active in promoting debit cards and internet banking, and both services are used far more often by Canadians.

Prices

In Canada prices have long tended to be higher. This has contributed to problems such as cross-border shopping and a reduced standard of living. Since the early 1990s this has not been the case, as the Canadian dollar had fallen low enough that it more than made up for price differences. Today prices are somewhat lower in Canada, the Big Mac Index shows that in 2003 a Big Mac cost $2.65 in the States and only $2.41 in Canada (both figures in USD).

Fuel prices have always been higher in Canada. Despite having large internal reserves, Canada does not have the international political influence to get the same low prices as the United States. Canada still has much lower fuel prices that Europe and Japan, however.

Productivity

By most measures Canadians workers are less productive, some of this difference is caused by Americans tending to work longer hours. Canadian levels of mechanization are also not always as high.

For the last thirty years the productivity gap has been closing, in large part because of the elimination of the smaller market problem through free trade. From 1961 to 1973 labour productivity rose annually by 3.3 percent in Canada and 1.7 percent in the United States. From 1973 to 1995 it was 1.1% in Canada and 0.8% in the States.

Unemployment

Canada has a higher unemployment rate than the United States with the Canadian number being around 7 to 8% while the U.S. tends to be around 5%. During the 1980s when this gap first emerged it was a controversial issue. Canada's higher income taxes and more generous benefit programs were blamed. It has recently been noted that a large percentage of the difference is caused by the two countries measuring the unemployment rate differently. More Americans who are out of work are not included in the unemployment roles. This idea was confirmed when both unemployment insurance and welfare were sharply cut in many parts of Canada during the 1990s, with little gain relative to the Americans.

Income

Canadian GDP per capita is lower than that in the United States, however median income is higher in Canada. Wealth in the United States is more highly concentrated and the higher per capita GDP is almost entirely a difference among the wealthiest 1% of the two countries.

The GDP gap has also been shrinking. From 1961 to 1973, real GDP grew at an average annual rate of 5.5 percent in Canada and 4.0 percent in the United States. From 1973 to 1995 it was 2.6% in Canada and 2.3% in the States.

Standard of Living

Standard of living is perhaps the hardest measurement to make since a wide array of factors have to be taken into account. The United Nations Human Development Index has traditionally listed Canada higher than the United States, with only a few exceptions. Other independent groups, such as the Economist rank Canadian cities as better places to live than American ones.

Canada beats the U.S. in statistics such as life expectancy, infant mortality, and literacy. The United States has more consumer goods than Canada. For instance, while Canada had only 714 televisions per 1000 people in 1996, the United States had 805.

Divisions in the United States are far larger. Most disturbing is the racial element's impact on poverty in the United States where African-Americans and Hispanics, on average, have a much lower standard of living than the rest of the population. Canada's French-Canadians used to also be a much poorer group, but since the 1960s this has mostly been remedied. Canada's First Nations do still have a far lower standard of living than the majority, but they are a much smaller percentage of the population than African-Americans are in the United States.

See also:

• Canadian and American politics compared
• Economy of Canada
• Economy of the United States

Referenced By